Friday 26 July 2019

Side by side : Paul John Peat

I received a couple of interesting drams from a sample swap with @dram_gazette and was able to split them to allow @ScotchB78 to join in the fun!


I've tried a few Paul John drams in my time so was really looking forward to these!

For those of you who don't know Paul John distillery is based in Goa on the west coast of India. 


Founded in 1992 Paul John use 6 row barley sourced from foothills of Himalayas. A high fiber and protein content, gives a  distinct tannic character to the spirit, the wash is more oily leading to a fruity whisky with floral notes. Due to the high temperature and humidity of Goa the whisky matures much more quickly than in Scotland.



DramChristmas Edition 2018Edited
Characteristics46% ABV, NCF, blend of unpeated, Oloroso finish and peated single malts matured in ex Bourbon & Oloroso hogsheads.46% ABV, NCF, blend of peated and unpeated single malts matured in ex-bourbon casks.
Distillery infoNose : Fabulous creamy sherry background with the blend of well-matured fruit cake, greengage and apple. Clean, luxuriously old fashioned Paul John with lots of honey, citrus and hazelnut. light smoke drifts around until it finds some spice.

Palate : Ultra fruity lushness with a combination of delicate spice, nut and sweetness.

Finish : Typical Spanish dry oloroso with a vaguely sweeter edge infused by notes of dry dates, figs and honey.
Nose : Honey and cocoa are laced with a hint of smokiness and a shot of espresso. A deeper whiff reveals fruity fragrances.

Palate : The grassy flavours of barley show up first, but gently make way for subtle peat notes. They slowly dissolve and pave the way for a rush of mint and mocha.

Finish : The finish is long and drawn out. You can sense a hint of spice and chocolate mint as it ends on gentle peat notes.
Appearance
A lovely bright gold colour in the glass, swirls stick and fall as slow thin legs - initial nose: spicy strawberry jam!Slightly paler than the Christmas edition, again swirls cling the the glass, this time falling as slow thick legs. Initial nose smoky hobnobs.
NoseBrianThere's definitely some peat smoke in there and loads of strawberry jam. There's dried fruit and Christmas spices. I think the peat balances the dunnage warehouse notes I was expecting - it's not quite Christmas in a glass - it's got an Indian smoky twist!Agree with the lemon cheesecake - it's got that biscuit bottom and a fancy citrus top. I think the smoke is more subtle than the Christmas edition. Brown sugar and honey give a sweet edge but there's also some milk chocolate there too.
ScottOn the nose I get an initial nose of honey, sticky strawberry jam, brass polish with a subtle hint of peat and sherry. There's also some sherbet dib dabs in there too!Very malty, not hugely peated, more costal for me, honey, lemon boiled sweets with biscuits. A smoked lemon cheesecake!
Agree, the smoke is less evident on this one.
PalateBrianCreamy arrival - hints of nuts and tropical fruit. The strawberry jam and spices from the nose follow on behind all wrapped in a blanket of smoke - yummy!
Getting some Terry's Chocolate Orange hints too - opening up nicely - still very Christmassy!
Quite a thick oily arrival, chocolate and spice on the palate and a thin veil of smoke. The brown sugar and honey from the nose are there. I was expecting a peat monster from some of the other reviews I've read but this is much gentler allowing the other notes to come through.
ScottVery gentle arrival, pretty dry and much more of a peated element than the nose suggested. Fruity yes, but something tea like too. Interesting.
Now you mention it yep, choc orange 👍
Oily, yep. Nice syrupy mouthfeel which is a winner in my book. Finishes with some dark chocolate bitterness, ginger nuts and a good helping of peat smoke. Lovely dram
FinishBrianA long spicy finish, loads of ginger, nutmeg and cinnamon - the smoke again covers it all with a blanket. Didn't get the drying effect I was expecting from the icing sugar note on the nose but overall a yummy dram! 🥃👍Spicy finish with a little of the citrus notes from the nose. This is where the smoke really comes in - but for me it's disappointing late. 😪
ScottDefinitely some mulled wine elements to this. Very spicy finish. Cloves, pepper and drying sherry notes. Yum. Might just be me, but I'm getting a hint of @Laphroaig on the finish of this.Strange that the smoke doesn't really get going till the finish. Liked both but think I preferred the Christmas one 🎄

I don't think the Edited lived up to the reputation I'd heard about it but the Christmas Edition was really nice, more than making up for it! Many thanks to @dram_gazette for the sample swap and @ScotchB78 for sharing these @PaulJohnWhisky drams with me!

@ScotchB78's photo of Edited (L) and Christmas (R) showing lovely legs

No comments: